Hi there, pandan!
I want to start off by saying that I got bit by the inspiration bug when I discovered hacks like Vision Quest, Eligor’s Spear, and Souls of the Forest. Collectively, they got me interested enough to make an account here and start learning how to make hacks of my own!
Gameplay: Your hack was the first hack I’ve ever completed, and it was a thrill to play from start to finish on Hard Mode. This FE veteran got wrecked a few times for his hubris, but the beauty of it all was that it never felt unfair! I could tell that enemy placements, character power levels, and map design were all carefully crafted for a smooth gameplay experience that honors the series’ past without clinging to certain traditions that are best left dead (like Armor Knights having 4 move). It was wonderful that the game favored well-measured aggression over scaredy-cat turtling to avoid being in range of surprise ambush spawns. I also must praise you for your design choice of giving the Warp staff more uses, but shorter range. It allowed me to make more fun plays without trivializing difficulty. That’s the sweet spot the mainline series should aim for in the future.
Music: Oh man, the variety was staggering! Not every choice fit the atmosphere of a Fire Emblem game in my mind, but I felt that the hits far outnumbered the misses. Chapter 1-7xx’s music choice in particular blew me away with how well it fit the situation! Also, the original compositions from you and your teammates were very well done. I still can’t get the title theme out of my head!
Story: At first, I wasn’t too impressed with the plot. Part 1 felt competent but not amazing in this regard. The main antagonist there felt more like a factory-generated obstacle than an intriguing opponent. Part 2 really amped the interest for me, though! I was a big fan of the shadiness of the Nevan court, the gradual buildup of the “dark forces,” and the eventual declaration of war that created tension between our leading men. Part 3 was an enjoyable look at the other side of the war with some cool inspiration from FE5’s Manster Escape arc. Part 4 brought it all together predictably, but there were nice surprises snuggled in between the typical lategame story beats. The final boss wasn’t exactly a climactic encounter of epicness, but the events of the epilogue were quite satisfying.
Characters: There’s a nice mix of ages, body types, hair styles, and cultural inspirations here! I’ve only done one playthrough, so I don’t know everyone’s personality well yet, but what I’ve seen so far is generally fun stuff. The support acquisition is just the way I like it. My Top 15 characters so far are Storch, Titus, Waluyo (Gasp! You made all the lords likable!), Mango, Duck, Zoya, Helga, Onisim, Nazar, Surya, Kir, Kusuma, Radoslav, Anisa, and Hollace. It might get shaken up a bit the next time I play, but these characters left the strongest first impression on me.
All in all, I’m thankful to you and your team for the fantastic game, as well as the creative inspiration! I look forward to learning more about hacking and playing more awesome hacks made by the community here.