[FE8] 64M exntention practice

Just wanted to share what we have learned about 64M ROM. The idea is borrowed from Pokémon hacks, with some AI support. TL;DR: We can put battle animation after 32M, and it works well. The step is writing in Chinese and you may need to have some kind of translation to read. In the future, we will share the ROM when everything is ready. We can only use a special emulator to play it. Maybe in the future we need some help from FEB to put resources after 32M.

battle-demo [FE8 Eirika-Variant] Halberdier [F] by TytheBub
F2U/F2E
Source: FE-Repo, Battle Animations/Lords - Vanilla and Custom
Imported: 2. Lance/Lance.bin and 8. Unarmed/Unarmed.bin

3 Likes

This says everything I need to know. If you need a custom emulator, why stop at 64 mb? You can have any arbitrary size. But who’s going to play it? The beauty of gba is compatibility: there are popular emulators for pretty much any system. I’d much rather have a 32 mb hard limit than severely cut my playerbase.

2 Likes

Good point! We can also go with an arbitrary size; 64 is just a practical example.

The goal here is to address concerns from a certain number of authors in China about capacity. They would like to include more battle animations and voice content in the ROM.

Regarding your question, I think it’s debatable whether FE fans would really care which emulator they use. Personally, I don’t think we’d lose players by going this route, especially compared to sticking with 32 and potentially not delivering a good enough experience.

1 Like

A custom emulator means people having to download software specifically for your hack instead of using the emulator already in their system, which immediately cuts down interest. And unless you make it mobile compatible, you will also lose a lot of players because lots of players play mobile.

Frankly if you are at the point where you need to make a custom emulator for your hack to get past hard GBA limits, I question why you’re making it a hack in the first place. If the hard GBA limits are a problem for you, then Lex Talionis has none. You can add as many animations and voice content into a LT game as you want.

2 Likes

I can understand the need for more space (though you really have to push the limit for 32 mb to be stiffing with proper memory management), but considering this solution require a custom emulator you may as well rip the bandage off and make a proper PC port to remove every limit at once, rather than asking people to download a weird emulator they don’t normally use

2 Likes

Yes I echo these points made by other commenters.

I’ve bandied around the idea of a ROM extension myself but when you consider the compromises you have to make with compatibility for it to even be playable you start wondering if GBA is even the right platform.

As someone who’s also adding voice content, I’ve found that with careful quality control you can fit in quite a bit inside 16MB. This can be extended further with access to the decomp to compress/remove data you aren’t using.

Sure this might have some niche appeal and it’s cool to have a working demo outside of the GBA movie videos, but I don’t see this being groundbreaking for the reasons everyone else has discussed.

Good luck with the project in any case :+1:

2 Likes

Multiple discs is the funny version. The cooler one.

That said this could be compatible with physical carts using bank switching or somethin’.

Could you please share the link to the Pokémon hack projects where the idea is borrowed and the modified emulator’s source code to help us understand it better? Thanks!