Monster Girl tier list thread

putting cyclopses in You’re Not a Monster to Me but not Elves is such cap

also is that fucking milking porn for the cowgirl entry? it’s low resolution so I can’t quite tell

EDIT: upon further reflection, it might not have been milking? it was removed anyway, though, so I guess it doesn’t matter now.

6 Likes

Eh, screw it, time to quickly throw one together.

6 Likes

8 Likes

I don’t know what this has to do with Fire Emblem…
so here are most of the monster girl animations I’ve made.

Magicdryd_st1Mermaid_la1ScytheScorpgalSlimegalWetgalLobsterBatgalIkki

Tier them or something idk ¯_(ツ)_/¯

21 Likes

Should I tier based on my monster girl preference or animation preference?

2 Likes

Not sure. I guess animation preference. I’m not sure what the difference would be.

Or just do both idk.

MONSTERS

SYMPHONE

drowned Promo

Staff

WAR BAEL

Bow

Bow(Ballista)

Monster

LAMIA:

Magic

Staff

Refresh

WOLF LAGUZ

Transform

detransform

Unarmed

BAEL EMPRESS

Bow

Magic

Monster

LIVING DOLL

Axe

Handaxe

Bow

Mine lol

6 Likes

…elves are monster girls? What?

5 Likes

Why are angels monster girls?

2 Likes

now we need to make another list for monster guys

equality

8 Likes

Err

Pot/Jar Snail Girl - has some magic, but seems completely immobile. That is a bit of a problem in a war, as armies are famously known for moving. D tier, could maybe be some kind of artillery if her jar is carried by some other guy but otherwise no.

Tree Girl - Same problem as before, but she also can’t attack or do anything except look pretty and provide food. Well, actually, that could be useful, assuming she can replenish those fruit at a reasonable rate - this would provide a source of food for the soldiers. Unfortunately with those roots it’s even less likely that she can keep up with the rest of the army. F tier.

Half-Fish Girl - she might be able to slither around, but 1) if she’s anything like real fish she is more likely to just flop around and her muscles aren’t built for slithering, and 2) if she has gills, we clearly have an issue with any land based combat. That trident does not seem aerodynamic but we can at least replace that with a standard issue javelin. C tier, could be a useful unit during sea combat.

Scythe Demon Girl - looks very good, high mobility, reflexes, also possible item warping/summoning and teleportation abilities. The only problem is that she seems easily distracted by blowing kisses at enemy soldiers, but this can be eradicated with enough discipline. I’ll give her an A tier.

Scorpion Girl - at least she can walk, that’s more than many previous girls, even if her mobility seems a little low. Her upper body seems like a weak point as the rest of her body appears naturally armored, but some specific armor sets could help offset that. Would be valuable as a slower, but high-breakthrough formation. B tier.

Slime Girl - I think consuming one’s enemies breaks the Geneva conventions somewhere. F tier.

Er, Water Slime Girl - Would be very useful due to her intangible liquid nature as well as natural weaponry, which means that she can serve in the army without basically any spending on equipment and weapons - and is likely quite difficult to kill. A tier.

Purple Haired Girl - doesn’t seem to do anything, just cheers on the rest? I’ll give her a D tier.

Bat Girl - several useful abilities, like warping/teleportation, bat transformation, and natural weaponry. However the Scythe Demon Girl fulfills the same niche and is far more mobile and seems to have better reflexes. B tier.

Ghost Girl - Assuming she phases through anything physical and can summon her giant evil faces basically anywhere, that’s an immediate S tier to me. You can’t really fight back against that, strong armor doesn’t help against this kind of attack either. You could deploy one and she would eventually win.

5 Likes

Not gonna rate mine?

4 Likes

S- Doll girl has a really nice design and I really like her alternate attacks too. Lots of love def went into it.

A- Wolf laguz and Baellista

Both of these are extremely awesome and fun to add. Baellista gives a nice new mechanic for monsters and gives variety than needing to have Bonewalkers or Wights with bows. Having mobile ballista on monsters is really nice

Wolf Laguz is very simplistic but it still gives that “Manakete” itch during the actual transformation. I don’t get tired of the transforming animation at all.

B- Symphones are awesome and are promoted drowned. Magic niche is awesome and I enjoy the fishbowl for a head!

C- Lamia and Bael Empress

I’m not big on snakes, but it’s definitely my preferred design over gorgons. I really like the tail wiggling a bit before the critical

Bael Empress is also cool. I really enjoy the fangs of the spider body being spread as she does her bow attack. I also love the magic circle that appears too

2 Likes

Now This is the type of analysis I come to this website for.

Huge misplay putting slime girls in D tier

2 Likes

My turn my turn

Symphone: I was actually unsure what this was but Hatsuru’s explanation helped. Its cool looking with the fish bowl and it seems like it has the niche of water walking. B Tier

War Bael: At first I was like, “Why would we weaponize a spider with artillery?” But then I remembered the Oliphaunts from LotR and realized that this is just the FE version of that. I got a good chuckle. Spooky from a distance and from a far. C+ Tier.

Lamia: Okay I heavily referenced this animation when working on one of my own. It has all of the perqs of FE8’s gorgons but look a lot nicer. Dark magic is good with enough con or speed, but she may be lacking in the Con department. Snakes are cool, Lamia’s are cool, my hack as a Lamia named Tuki. so yeah, boxes checked. S Tier

Wolf Laguz: that transformation is S Tier alone. I love FE9 and FE10. (FE10>FE9 fight me) They are fast, strong and have little downsides. S Tier.

Quelaag: That bow charge animation is sick. While it does use the base spider animation, but you threw on top of it is exceptional. The magic effects are nice and the bow is awesome. Would most likely have good movement, strong might and magic, and would be an overal scary enemy to fight. A Tier.

Living Doll: S Tier for creativity alone, The Animation itself is also perfect. Not sure how it fits in with FE, but who cares. S Tier,

3 Likes

i did a slime a while back… dont know how to format so uhhh uhhh uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
DQSLIME

8 Likes

I find some of this a bit hard to watch.

I think it would be better if some of y’all don’t reply in the future if you have nothing serious to add to the conversation.

I’ve seen this happen on other off-topic threads and it rubs me the wrong way.

6 Likes

This post isn’t gonna be safe forever…Ragnarok will come upon you all and your precious monster girls mwhahahaha.

4 Likes